Losses to Autonomy and the Unending Nightmare for H-P


            While the news broke surrounding Hewlett Packard’s sudden write-down of its November 2011 acquisition of Autonomy nearly two weeks ago, developments continue to plague H-P as it settles this mammoth blunder. 
            On November 20th, H-P’s stock went tumbling 12% as the company announced a massive $8.8B write-down, primarily tied to its acquisition of Autonomy.  H-P directly accused Autonomy of "serious accounting improprieties, disclosure failures and outright misrepresentations".  The Founder of Autonomy, Michael Lynch, has openly rejected these accusations, and has gone as far as sending an open letter to H-P’s board asking for an explanation of what these supposed “accounting improprieties” are.     
            Unfortunately, the write-down of Autonomy is only the most recent in a slieu of problems that have been plaguing H-P as the stock has fallen over 50% this year, amid management turnover, decreased product demand, and growing debt. 
            While it might seem permissible for a company to have large write-downs in the case of accounting misrepresentations, too many flags have been thrown to look at this as a one-sided mistake.  The market was openly pessimistic about H-P’s acquisition from the beginning.  From the time H-P announced the Autonomy acquisition to the time the deal was completed, H-P’s market capitalization dropped $15B from $58.5B to $43.5B.  Additionally, H-P’s share price drop of 12% on the $8.8B write-down announcement represented a $3B drop in the company’s market capitalization, implying that the market had already priced in a $5.5B loss. 
            One of the most appalling details about the Autonomy write-down is the uncanny resemblance of the acquisition write-down to the original acquisition premium.  H-P originally paid a $5.2B acquisition premium on Autonomy back in 2011.  Now it has made a $5B write-down on that original acquisition ($3.8B of the original $8.8B write-down was not due to Autonomy).
            A year after H-P’s acquisition, the company has written down nearly the entirety of its original acquisition premium.  Even if Autonomy is guilty of the accounting misrepresentation it is accused of, can anyone really find H-P free of blame?             

-Kyle Cameron

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ireland's Economic Comeback

Image
On Wednesday, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) released a billion dollars of financial help to Ireland, as the country complied with the requirements set up in its 2010 bailout plan. The plan, which saved Ireland from bankruptcy after it suffered a massive banking crisis starting 2008, is reaching its end, as Ireland is getting ready to start issuing sovereign debt again in December. However, the country has to reach a minimum annual growth of 2% for its debt to become sustainable. Ireland is now out of its second recession in five years with a 0.4% second quarter expansion. This positive data, however, falls short of the optimistic 1.3% growth over the entire year predicted by the Irish government. Irish exports have grown by 4.3% over the same period, while household consumption grew by 0.7%. The IMF decision came almost one week after other good news for Ireland: on Friday, September 20, Moody's announced positive forecasts on Ireland's sovereign debt, which it now judg
Read more

Ongoing Contact

Students today commonly use Twitter and Facebook and, therefore, they receive lots of information on a regular basis. Information comes to them in small bits many times each day. Therefore, the 48 to 72 hours between class meetings can seem like an eternity. It is little wonder that students often seem incapable of remembering what took place in the previous class meeting. The amount of correspondence they have received in the interim is probably massive. I don’t use Twitter because I can’t write anything in 140 characters but I use email A LOT. I want to keep the students engaged in the period between my classes. I want them to think about Financial Accounting every day not just when they are walking into class. The emails that I send to my students vary enormously from motivational to practice questions to simply informational. I often ask the students about these emails in class so they know they need to read them. Yesterday was our first class where we discussed ow
Read more

Obama pushes for diplomacy on Iran's nuclear program

Image
President Obama and Iranian President Hassan Rouhani both openly stated their support for a new diplomatic effort regarding Iran's nuclear program. Obama, addressing the UN General Assembly on Tuesday, stated that there was "basis for a meaningful agreement." In recent weeks, Rouhani, who was elected in June, has suggested that he is open to developing a program in which Iran is allowed to further their nuclear energy program but prevents them from building a weapon, claiming that a nuclear weapon program would "contradict our fundamental religious and ethical convictions." Obama said that Secretary of State John Kerry was working with the Iranian government to resolve the negotiations about Iran's nuclear program. In his statement to the UN General Assembly, he stated that success in the negotiations would be a "major step in a long road to a difficult relationship, one based on mutual interests and mutual respect," adding that "the roadblock
Read more